These can be painful viewing as IDers and creationists can often be much slicker debaters than those from the evolution side. Which to be honest, nobody should mind, I'd rather trust good science than good PR. However I think its a useful exercise to be familiar with ID/creo arguments for several reasons: 1) challenges to a working theory are healthy and remind us not to resort to intellectual laziness or groupthink, 2) some of their objections are not easily answered by the average evolution accepting layperson or even those familiar with the science, and 3) nobody wants to look stupid at social events, being stumped for a comeback when the token 'skeptic' pops up. Some arguments are of course hideously obvious in their shortcomings, like the old "why are there still monkeys?" or "there are no transitional fossils". But its more difficult if somebody confidently asserts something like "there are not enough beneficial genetic mutations for natural selection to be a creative rather than simply whittling force". It isn't immediately very easy to refute this without some technical knowledge.
To this end, I thought it would be helpful to post a list of some classic evolution versus ID/creationism debates and some further resources for your perusal...
Barry Lynn, Eugenie Scott, Michael Ruse, and Kenneth Miller vs. William F. Buckley Jr., Phillip Johnson, Michael Behe, and David Berlinski, December 1997
PZ Myers vs. Geoffrey Simmonds, January 2008
Peter Ward vs. Stephen Meyer, May 2008
Michael Shermer vs. Jonathan Wells, December 2008
Michael Shermer and Don Prothero vs. Stephen Meyer and Rick Sternberg, December 2009
The ID/creationist arguments are generally horribly flawed, though some more so than others, but importantly, they make you think, and some of the evolution rebuttals are not quite satisfying, so I think overall they are worth watching if you can bear it.
An extremely useful follow up resource can then be found at talkorigins.org's Index to Creationist Claims which comprises hundreds of useful bits of information all in one convenient location (if you'll excuse their 1995 web design). Its also available as an Iphone app I think!
Happy debating!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment